Why athletes approach or avoid challenges: how personality and the situation combine, what drives task choice and persistence, and how coaches can change the balance.
Achievement motivation explains why people approach, persist in or avoid achievement situations, such as competitions, tests and difficult training. Atkinson's model proposes that this depends on two personality tendencies, the motive to achieve success and the motive to avoid failure, and on situational factors such as the probability of success and the incentive value of success. The balance between the approach and avoidance tendencies predicts how an athlete will feel and behave. Coaches can influence this balance by changing the situation, for example by setting tasks at a suitable level and focusing on personal progress.
Achievement motivation can be followed as a chain. The personality factors are the performer's tendency to seek achievement (Ms) and to avoid failure (Maf). The situational factors include the probability of success, the difficulty of the task, the importance of the outcome and the feedback given by others. Together they produce a resultant tendency: approach if the motive to achieve success is stronger, avoidance if the motive to avoid failure is stronger. This tendency then produces an emotion (pride and confidence, or fear and anxiety) and behaviour (choosing, persisting with or avoiding the task).
In Atkinson's model, the resultant tendency is often written as:
Achievement motivation = Ms − Maf
The motive to achieve success is the product of the probability of success and the incentive value of success (Ms = Ps × Is). The motive to avoid failure depends on fear of failure, the probability of failure and the negative incentive value of failure. Because Ps + Pf = 1, a task that is easy (high Ps) carries little incentive for a performer who wants to succeed, and a task that is very hard (low Ps) carries little risk of a personal failure. This is why the two motives lead to different task choices.
The model predicts that performers with a strong motive to achieve success prefer tasks of moderate difficulty, where success is realistic but not certain, and that they persist longer in these tasks. Performers with a strong fear of failure prefer very easy or very hard tasks: very easy tasks protect against failure, and very hard tasks give a ready explanation for failing. This pattern is shown in the schematic curves below. The model is a simplified prediction; real preferences vary between individuals and situations.
In sport, this helps explain behaviour such as a player who avoids taking responsibility in a tense match, or an athlete who only enters races they are sure to win. Recognising the pattern lets a coach adjust the task instead of simply pushing the athlete harder.
Performers also differ in how they define success. A task-oriented performer judges success by personal progress, skill development, effort and learning. An ego-oriented performer judges success by outperforming others. Task-oriented performers are more likely to persist after failure, because they interpret failure as information for improvement rather than as a judgement of their ability. This links to attribution and locus of control (see C.1.2).
Because achievement motivation depends on the situation as well as personality, coaches can shift the balance towards approach and away from avoidance by changing the environment:
Atkinson's model has been useful for explaining task choice, but it has limitations. It treats motives as fixed personality tendencies, although they can change with experience and coaching. The measures of motives and of the incentive value of success are hard to define and to test in real sport. The model also focuses on individual motivation, and does not fully capture team and social influences, or the role of goals and the coach. It is best used as one tool among several, to help understand and guide behaviour rather than to predict it exactly.
Write your answer first, then open the model answer to check it.
Simply Sport Science is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by the International Baccalaureate Organization, Cambridge University Press & Assessment or Pearson/BTEC. All course and exam-board names are used only to identify the specifications the materials support.